SimuVeda

Environment · Simulator 088

Carbon Cycle

Carbon moves between the air, the surface ocean, the deep ocean and plants and soils. Fossil fuel emissions add carbon to the air, and the ocean and land slowly take some of it back. Choose a future emissions path and change how quickly each reservoir exchanges carbon, then track CO₂ in the air and where the carbon ends up.

How the model works

The model is a box model: four reservoirs with preindustrial stocks of 590 GtC (atmosphere), 900 (surface ocean), 37,100 (deep ocean) and 2,300 (vegetation and soils). Each pair exchanges carbon at rates that balance exactly before 1850 (60, 90 and 120 GtC per year). Emissions E enter the atmosphere:

dA/dt = E − F(air→ocean) + F(ocean→air) − F(photosynthesis) + F(respiration)

Three effects shape the uptake. The Revelle (buffer) factor R: seawater chemistry means a 1% rise in dissolved carbon raises the ocean's CO₂ pressure by about R%, so the surface ocean fills up quickly (R ≈ 10 today). Deep mixing slowly carries carbon down, where it stays for centuries. CO₂ fertilization: plants grow faster in richer air, so photosynthesis rises by β × ln(A/A₀).

Atmospheric CO₂ in ppm is A / 2.12. The airborne fraction is the share of all carbon ever emitted that is still in the air. Historical emissions (fossil fuels and land use) are modelled as a smooth rise reaching 11 GtC per year in 2020, about 700 GtC in total.

A teaching model: linear exchanges, no temperature feedbacks (warming oceans and soils release carbon in reality), no sediments or weathering, and only rough agreement with history. Complex Earth-system models differ in how quickly CO₂ falls after emissions stop.

Guided experiments

  1. Calibrate on history. Default settings, any scenario, look at 2020. Prediction: about 408 ppm in 2020 (measured: about 412), with roughly 39% of the 700 GtC emitted still in the air.
  2. Hold emissions constant. 11 GtC per year forever. Prediction: CO₂ keeps rising, past 530 ppm by 2100 and about 640 by 2200: constant emissions do not mean constant CO₂, because the sinks cannot keep pace.
  3. Net zero by 2050. Emissions fall in a straight line to zero. Prediction: CO₂ peaks near 422 ppm in the mid-2030s, while emissions are still well above zero, then falls as the ocean and land keep absorbing: about 411 ppm in 2050 and 376 ppm by 2100.
  4. Ocean chemistry matters. Constant emissions with a Revelle factor of 1 (an ocean that is not buffered). Prediction: the ocean would absorb far more: only about 337 ppm in 2020 and 364 ppm in 2100, instead of 408 and 533. The real ocean's buffer chemistry is a major reason CO₂ stays high.

Challenge

In the constant-emissions scenario, the airborne fraction slowly falls after 2020, yet CO₂ keeps rising. How can both be true?

Reveal the explanation

The airborne fraction is the carbon remaining in the air divided by everything ever emitted. Cumulative emissions keep growing by 11 GtC every year, and the sinks grow too as CO₂ rises, so the fraction drifts down (0.39 in 2020, about 0.34 in 2100). But the airborne amount still grows every year, because the sinks take up less than 11 GtC per year. CO₂ can only stabilize when emissions fall to the size of the sinks.

References

  • Friedlingstein, P. et al. (2023), "Global Carbon Budget 2023", Earth System Science Data 15: 5301–5369.
  • Sarmiento, J. L. and Gruber, N., Ocean Biogeochemical Dynamics (2006), ch. 8 and 10.
  • Revelle, R. and Suess, H. E. (1957), "Carbon dioxide exchange between atmosphere and ocean", Tellus 9(1): 18–27.